Claims

Claims Contacts - Specialty Divisions

AgriBusiness®

301 E Fourth Street , 26th Floor
Cincinnati, OH 45202-4201
513 763 8550
800 567 7359
513 763 8549 fax

Steve Heffelmire
Divisional Vice President
513 763 8505
sheffelmire@gaic.com

Alternative Markets Division

301 E Fourth Street, 24th Floor
Cincinnati, OH 45202-4201
877 589 6846
888 223 1317 fax

Thomas Jabs
Divisional Senior Vice President
513 287 8132
tjabs@gaic.com 

Bond Division

301 E Fourth Street, 24th Floor
Cincinnati, OH 45202-4201
513 369 5000
513 369 5027 fax

Dave Kitchin
Divisional Senior Vice President
513 412 4602
dkitchin@gaic.com

Crop Insurance Division

301 E Fourth Street, 26th Floor
Cincinnati, OH 45202-4201
513 763 8400
800 587 1553 Ext. 8417
513 763 8457 fax

Bob Twomey
Divisional Assistant Vice President
513 763 8416
btwomey@gaic.com

Equine Mortality Division

4414 S.W. College Road, Ste 1422
Ocala, FL 34474
800 331 0211
513 345 1362 fax

Kathy Coyne
Divisional Assistant Vice President
352 369 4147
kjcoyne@gaic.com

Excess Liability

500 Lanidex Plz
Parsippany, NJ 07054
973 952 9857 fax

Jim Siessel
Divisional Vice President
973 958 9888
jsiessel@gaic.com

Ellen Biondo
Divisional Vice President
973 958 9780
ebiondo@gaic.com
Executive Liability Division

1515 Woodfield Road, Suite 500
Schaumburg, IL 60173-5499
847 330 6750
513 864 3750 fax

Kevin Gadbois
Divisional Executive Vice President
Claims
847 330 6763
eldclaims@gaic.com

Equipment Finance Solutions

15325 SE 30th Place, Suite 100
Bellevue, WA 98007

Chris Wright, AIC
Senior Claim Manager
425 649 6084
800 833 3549
888 719 4793 fax
cwright@gaic.com

FCIA Management Company

125 Park Avenue, 14th Floor
New York, NY 10017
212 885 1500
212 885 1535 fax

Carol McEvoy
Senior Vice President
212 885 1508
cmcevoy@fcia.com

Financial Institution Services

301 E Fourth Street, 20th Floor 
Cincinnati, OH  45202-4201
877 429 3826
800 838 4013 fax

Pat Sinnard
Assistant Vice President
877 429 3826
psinnard@gaic.com

Lawyers Professional Group

2435 N. Central Expressway
Richardson, TX 75080
800 531 2297
972 437 7144 fax

Great American Custom

725 South Figueroa Street, Suite 3400
Los Angeles, CA 90017-2592
213 430 4300
800 687 4453
213 683 8004 fax

Lori Reilly
Vice President
213 430 4396
lori.reilly@gamcustom.com

Ocean Marine Division/East

65 Broadway, 20th Floor
New York, NY 10006-2503
212 510 0104 
800 426 9697
800 498 2178 fax

Frank Skelly
Divisional Senior Vice President
212 510 0102
fskelly@gaic.com

Ocean Marine Division/West

1350 Treat Blvd.
Walnut Creek, CA 94596-2133
925 935 8557
925 935 8636 fax

Tom Nager 
Divisional Vice President
925 988 2225
tnager@gaic.com

Property/Inland Marine Division

301 E Fourth Street, 21st Floor
Cincinnati, OH 45202-4201
800 584 0835
800 811 4751 fax

Josh Schaad
513 333 6914
jschaad@gaic.com
pimclaims@gaic.com

Specialty Automotive Services Division

301 E Fourth Street, 20th Floor
Cincinnati, OH 45202-4201
877 429 3826
800 838 4013 fax

Pat Sinnard
Assistant Vice President
877 429 3826
psinnard@gaic.com 

Specialty Human Services Division

301 E Fourth Street, 23rd Floor
Cincinnati, OH 45202-4201
513 333 6962
888 317 4828
888 307 3180 fax

Doug Svenkerud
Divisional Vice President
513 287 8170
dsvenkerud@gaic.com

Specialty E&S

301 E Fourth Street, 25th Floor
Cincinnati, OH  45202-4201
513 579 6300
513 412 4157 fax

Brian DeSoto
Vice President
513 287 8156
Brian.DeSoto@gamcustom.com

Trucking Division

301 E Fourth Street, 22nd Floor
Cincinnati, OH 45202-4201
800 643 7882
513 333 6998 fax

William Riemen
Divisional Vice President, Claims
800 297 1971
wriemen@gaic.com

Claims Contacts - Affiliates

American Empire Group

301 E Fourth Street, 25th Floor
Cincinnati, OH 45202-4201
513 369 3000
513 369 3062 fax

Larry Potrafke
Senior Vice President
513 369 3717
lpotrafke@gaic.com

National Interstate

3250 Interstate Drive
Richfield, OH 44286-9000
330 659 8900
800 929 1500
330 659 8901 fax

Terry Phillips
Senior Vice President
330 659 8900
terry.phillips@nationalinterstate.com  

Mid-Continent Group

1437 South Boulder, Suite 200
Tulsa, OK 74119-3693
918 587 7221
800 722 4994
918 588 1294 fax

Kirby Pancoast
Senior Vice President
918 588 1270
kpancoast@mcg-ins.com

Republic Indemnity

15821 Ventura Blvd.
Encino, CA 91436-2936
818 990 9860
800 821 4520
818 986 6559 fax

Dave Mitchell
Senior Vice President
818 382 1100
davem@ri-net.com

 

Submit An Inquiry

Long standing relationships with great agent partners are at the core of our business.  If you have any questions please submit an inquiry to contactus@gaic.com.

 

 
  • Mail
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
American Financial Group
(AFG)
is a holding company
based in Cincinnati, Ohio. It is a
Fortune 500 company whose
common stock is listed on the
New York Stock Exchange and
NASDAQ. The members of
Great American Insurance
Group are subsidiaries of AFG.
Corporate Headquarters
Great American Insurance Group Tower
301 E Fourth Street
Cincinnati, OH  45202
1-513-369-5000